
Sugar-Free Isn't the Same as Harmless: My Take on the Erythritol Research

Erythritol is everywhere at the moment. Keto chocolate, protein bars, flavoured water, sugar-free ice cream, and a good share of the "natural" sweeteners sitting on the shelf next to the stevia. People reach for it because it tastes clean, has next to no kilojoules and barely shifts blood sugar.
For a long time that seemed like enough. I'm not so sure anymore.
Where the Worry Started
Back in 2023, researchers at the Cleveland Clinic published a paper in Nature Medicine that made a lot of us in the natural health world sit up. They followed several thousand adults across the US and Europe and found that people with the most erythritol in their blood were more likely to have a heart attack or stroke over the next three years.
Then they tried something much simpler. Healthy volunteers drank one beverage sweetened with 30 grams of erythritol. Their blood levels shot up and stayed high for days, and in the lab their platelets (the cells that help blood clot) turned noticeably jumpier.
An association isn't proof. It did leave a fair question hanging, though. What is this stuff actually doing to our blood vessels?
What Happened to the Brain's Blood Vessel Cells
A team at the University of Colorado Boulder went looking for an answer and published it in the Journal of Applied Physiology. They grew human cells from the lining of the brain's smallest blood vessels. Unassuming little cells, but they do an enormous amount of quiet work: opening and narrowing vessels as needed, keeping inflammation down, and breaking up small clots before they turn into big problems.
The cells sat in erythritol for three hours, at roughly the level you'd get from a single sugar-free drink (about 30 grams). Then they were compared with cells left alone.
Free radicals climbed sharply, even though the cells tried to fight back by ramping up their own antioxidant enzymes. Nitric oxide, the molecule that lets blood vessels relax and widen, fell by close to 20%. Endothelin-1, which does the opposite and tightens them, went up.
The last finding is the one that stuck with me. When the researchers sent a clotting signal, the untreated cells answered by releasing more t-PA, the body's own clot-dissolving protein. The erythritol-treated cells hardly responded at all.
So much of what I do with herbs and nutrition for circulation is about supporting nitric oxide and keeping blood flowing freely. Seeing a common sweetener nudge things the other way, even in a dish, gave me pause.
A Bit of Perspective
I don't want to overstate this. These were cells in a dish, not people. One dose, a few hours. Nobody yet knows what years of daily use does, and the researchers are upfront about that. Erythritol is also still approved for use in food.
Still, the human data came first, and now there's lab work suggesting how the harm might happen. When two separate lines of evidence start pointing the same way, I'd rather err on the side of caution. That goes double for anyone already watching their heart or blood pressure.
How I'd Cut Back
You don't need to clear out the pantry in a panic. Start with the label. On Australian packaging, erythritol might be listed by name, as sweetener (968), or tucked away under "sugar alcohols" in the nutrition panel.
Then have a really good look at anything sold as monk fruit. Most monk fruit sweeteners on the market are predominantly erythritol, often around 99%, with only about 1% monk fruit extract. Pure monk fruit is so intensely sweet that it has to be bulked out to measure cup for cup, and erythritol is the filler of choice. Plenty of stevia blends are made the same way. The front of the packet says monk fruit. The ingredient list tells you what you're actually eating.
It also helps to know where the big doses hide. A sugar-free soft drink. A scoop of keto baking mix. The protein bar you grab every afternoon. Those add up quickly, and they're nothing like the trace amounts found naturally in grapes or pears.
My honest preference? Let real food do most of the sweetening. Berries, a ripe pear, a small drizzle of good raw honey. You get fibre and minerals along with the sweetness, which is how traditional diets always worked. If you sweeten your tea or yoghurt, try halving it for a fortnight. Most people are surprised how quickly their taste buds settle.
Where Allulose Comes In
Some people aren't ready to give up their sweet coffee, and some love to bake. For them, I usually suggest allulose. It's a rare sugar, found in small amounts in figs, raisins and maple syrup. It tastes like sugar and browns and caramelises like sugar in the oven, at about 70% of the sweetness and with very few kilojoules. Most of it passes straight through the body, so it has little effect on blood glucose.
It's a completely different molecule from erythritol and isn't a sugar alcohol. It wasn't tested in either study, so I won't claim the research says anything about it. A little is still better than a lot.
My Bottom Line
Sugar-free has never automatically meant good for you. The science on erythritol is still coming in, and I'll keep you posted as it does. In the meantime, read your labels properly and lean on real food.
Julyet, iSage Health
Healing with Tradition, Science & Wisdom
This article is general information only and is not medical advice. Please speak with your healthcare practitioner before making changes to your diet, particularly if you have a heart or circulatory condition or take blood-thinning medication.
References
- Berry AR, et al. The non-nutritive sweetener erythritol adversely affects brain microvascular endothelial cell function. Journal of Applied Physiology, 2025.
- Witkowski M, et al. The artificial sweetener erythritol and cardiovascular event risk. Nature Medicine, 2023.
Follow iSage Health

